Taking science AND faith seriously.
Episodes
7 hours ago
7 hours ago
50 min
Image: St. Dominic at prayer by El Greco.
https://www.artchive.com/artwork/st-dominic-praying-el-greco-c-1588-spain/
St. Dominic 1170 - 1221
Here I take up the opportunity offered by Francis and John Paul I and suggest a name that I believe is quite ripe for the picking to be added to the list of papal names.
Remarkable points from the Catholic Encyclopedia:
• Dominic was from a saintly family and a younger brother, Manes, joined the Dominican order.
• He studied for ten years at the University of Palencia.
• At a very young age he was recruited to help the Bishop of Osma reform his cathedral chapter.
• He stumbled into the Albigensians in southern France when he was sent as part of an embassy to court a Danish (?) princess on behalf of Prince Ferdinand of Castile.
• She died while en route back to Castile and this left Dominic at loose ends. He thus began working to confront the Albigensians with preaching and personal sanctity.
• The Cistercians had been entrusted with this mission, but were too worldly in that epoch.
• Preaching to women was a key part of this effort and led Dominic to establish a female order early on.
• A Simon de Montfort (remember that this was the early 13th century and the Norman kings of England still ruled much of southwest France) went on crusade after one of the Cistercian leaders was assassinated in 1208. For all that Dominic himself did not engage in violence he cooperated with Simon and was thought of very highly by that captain.
• The connection with the rosary seems to be indirect. Dominic was praying for a successful outcome to the battle of Muret, which in fact went miraculously well and Simon dedicated a chapel in the church where Dominic had been praying dedicated to Our Lady of the Rosary, showing that the rosary was already known.
• Dominic did not found the Inquisition and may never have been part of it. It was active in the Albigensian area (associated with the Cistercians?) already in 1198, while Dominic was still a canon living in virtual seclusion in Osma.
• Dominic refused many elections as bishop and said he would run away in the night rather than accept.
• He attended the Fourth Lateran Council (1215), which had the same "pastoral" focus that Dominic had, but was opposed to establishing any new religious orders and particularly any new Rules. Dominic had the backing of a local bishop and so for a time the Dominicans were limited to the diocese of Toulouse under Bishop Foulques, and they used the Rule of St Augustine (an intriguing point at present). He was then able to get papal approval in 1216, the year after the Council closed, essentially as a branch of the Augustinians.
• He was the Lenten preacher to the Curia in 1217.
• Dominic, whose university education had been invaluable for over a decade in preaching and debating Albigensians, wanted the same benefit for his friars and sent "Matthew of France" and two brothers to the University of Paris--so this connection goes back, indirectly, to Dominic himself. He also sent Dominicans to the University of Bologna.
• Dominic spent the next few years on constant visitation, traveling from Rome to Spain and back, founding friaries and convents along the way.
• The Dominicans took up Pope Honorius' invitation to preach against heresy in Lombardy. This was Dominic's final great project, and shortly afterward he died.
The case for a Pope Dominic: The name Dominic represents the highest standard of intellectual achievement alongside fervent faith, asceticism, and persuasive preaching. A pope taking this name could look to emphasize any of these facets of his life and legacy.
More discussion from Magisterium AI:
"St Dominic (Dominic of Caleruega, or Guzmán) was born in Castile around 1170 and died in Bologna on 6 August 1221. The broad outline of his life is well established, though many colorful details—especially stories of visions and miracles—come from devotional accounts and should be distinguished from the firmer historical record. Pope Benedict XVI summarizes his defining vocation as a life devoted to prayer, preaching, and the salvation of souls. 1 2
Dominic studied at Palencia, where he became known for his learning and concern for the poor; a famous account says he sold his books during a famine to help those in need. He later served as a canon and then prior at Osma. On journeys with Bishop Diego of Osma, he encountered the religious crisis in southern France and committed himself to preaching there. He preached by word and by an austere example of life; Alban Butler’s account emphasizes that his methods against heresy were instruction, patience, prayer, and penance—not violence. 1 2 3 4
Around this mission, Dominic gathered a community of preachers. The Order of Preachers—later known as the Dominicans—received papal confirmation in 1216. Dominic sent friars to establish communities and places of study across Europe, and the order grew rapidly. He died in poverty, leaving his brethren a final exhortation to charity, humility, and voluntary poverty. 5 6 7
Biographies and starting points
Three substantial biographies worth considering are:
• Pierre Mandonnet and H.-M. Vicaire, S. Dominique, l’idée, l’homme et l’œuvre (2 vols., 1937–38). Butler calls this the “definitive work” in his account of the literature on Dominic. It is the strongest choice here for a detailed historical study, though it is in French. 8
• Mother Frances Raphael Drane, The History of St. Dominic, Founder of the Friar Preachers (1891). Butler identifies it as one of the best original lives in English. It is a substantial older biography, best read with awareness that historical methods and scholarship have since developed. 8
• Fr. Bede Jarrett, Saint Dominic and the Order of Preachers (1924). Butler also lists this among the best original English lives. It offers a Dominican author’s account of the saint and the order he founded. 8
For an early, near-contemporary perspective rather than a modern biography, begin with the life by Blessed Jordan of Saxony, Dominic’s successor as head of the order; Butler notes that it is the starting point for the early biographical material. 7
[1] General Audience of 3 February 2010, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/a7b79d58-fa61-4e68-bc3f-0fac17ed1d67/ref/page1
[2] General Audience of 3 February 2010: Saint Dominic Guzman, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/91f76554-dad9-47e8-ab8d-362f7afaf303/ref/page1
[3] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page264. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page264
[4] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page262. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page262
[5] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page265. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page265
[6] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page266. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page266
[7] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page267. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page267
[8] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page268. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page268
Q2
Here are the dates supported by the available references:
• St Dominic: c. 1170–1221. 1
• St Albert the Great: c. 1206–1280; his birth year is uncertain, with some accounts giving 1205 or 1206. 2
• St Thomas Aquinas: c. 1224/25–1274; sources differ on his precise birth year. 3 4
Other Dominican scholastics whose names appear in the references include Hugh of Saint-Cher, Roland of Cremona, Richard Fitzacre, Peter of Tarentaise, and Robert of Kilwardby. The references identify them as notable Dominican scholars but do not give their birth and death years, so I can’t responsibly supply dates for them from the available evidence. 5
[1] General Audience of 3 February 2010: Saint Dominic Guzman, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/91f76554-dad9-47e8-ab8d-362f7afaf303/ref/page1
[2] Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Albertus Magnus. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/f2c979a8-871d-4f46-a059-320d3b837a76/ref/St.%20Albertus%20Magnus
[3] General Audience of 2 June 2010: Saint Thomas Aquinas, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/2b20e842-e703-4dac-979e-c1973c7ba480/ref/page1
[4] Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Thomas Aquinas. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/f2c979a8-871d-4f46-a059-320d3b837a76/ref/St.%20Thomas%20Aquinas
[5] Catholic Encyclopedia, Order of Preachers. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/f2c979a8-871d-4f46-a059-320d3b837a76/ref/Order%20of%20Preachers
Q3
The clearest documented chain is Dominic → Jordan of Saxony → Albert the Great → Thomas Aquinas—but it is a chain of influence and Dominican formation, not a series of personal meetings. Dominic died in 1221; Albert entered the Order after hearing Jordan preach, and Thomas, born around 1224–25, became a Dominican and then studied under Albert. Peter of Tarentaise is also linked to Albert and Thomas through work on Dominican study regulations. For the other early Dominican scholars named earlier, the available evidence does not establish a comparably specific personal chain back to Dominic.
The strongest links in the network
Dominic and Jordan of Saxony
Jordan is the firmest bridge from Dominic’s personal leadership to the Order’s next generation. He succeeded Dominic as master general in 1222 and wrote an early account of the Order’s beginnings. In that account, as quoted by Pope Benedict XVI, Jordan remembers Dominic as embracing people in charity and sharing their joys and sorrows. This is valuable testimony from a successor who knew Dominic, though the evidence here does not supply detailed episodes of their private relationship. 1 2
Dominic’s influence also passed through the institutions he established. He instructed his friars in preaching, teaching, study, and personal holiness, then sent them out to found communities and preach in different places. The young Order quickly developed a university presence: Dominican communities were founded in Paris and Bologna during Dominic’s lifetime. 3 4
Jordan and Albert
This is the best-documented link between the first generation and Albert. While studying at Padua, Albert encountered the Dominicans and heard Jordan preach. Pope Benedict XVI describes Albert’s entry as a gradual decision, influenced by Jordan’s preaching and the friars’ example; Albert received the habit from Jordan. Thus Albert’s connection to Dominic is mediated through Jordan and the Order, not a reported personal encounter with Dominic. 5
The exact date of Albert’s entry is not settled by the supplied material: one account places it in 1223, while another associates Jordan with receiving Albert among postulants in 1222. The sound conclusion is that Albert entered after Dominic’s death, under Jordan’s leadership. 6 7
Albert and Thomas
Albert and Thomas had a direct, well-attested teacher–student relationship. Benedict XVI says Thomas was sent to Paris in 1245 to study theology under Albert, and that they developed a deep friendship. A modern scholarly study places their shared residence at the Paris Dominican priory of Saint-Jacques from 1246 to 1248 and describes Albert as Thomas’s mentor. The dating and descriptions are compatible: the papal account gives the broad sequence, while the study specifies their common residence. 8 9
Thomas was attracted to the Dominican ideal in Naples, but the evidence here does not document a direct personal line from Dominic to Thomas. Indeed, Thomas was born around 1224–25, several years after Dominic’s death, so the connection is necessarily through Dominic’s Order and its members, not through meeting its founder. 10
Albert, Thomas, and Peter of Tarentaise
Peter of Tarentaise—later Pope Innocent V—is linked to Albert and Thomas through a Dominican institutional setting. The Catholic Encyclopedia account of Albert reports that Albert, Thomas, and Peter were associated at the Order’s General Chapter at Valenciennes in 1250, where rules for Dominican studies and academic degrees were drawn up. This connects Peter to the same educational and institutional world as Albert and Thomas, though it does not show a personal relationship between Peter and Dominic. 6
What can be said about the other early scholars?
• Hugh of Saint-Cher: The available material does not document a personal meeting or teacher–student relationship linking him to Dominic, Albert, or Thomas. One scholarly excerpt mentions Albert’s use of the teaching of a “Hugh,” but it does not establish that this is Hugh of Saint-Cher; it should not be used to claim a link between the Dominican Hugh and Albert. 11
• Roland of Cremona: No direct relationship with Dominic, Albert, or Thomas is documented in the material available here.
• Richard Fitzacre: No direct relationship with Dominic, Albert, or Thomas is documented here.
• Robert of Kilwardby: No direct relationship with Dominic, Albert, or Thomas is documented here.
For these three, and for Hugh of Saint-Cher, the Order’s shared institutions and historical succession provide a broad context, but that is not the same as evidence of contact. The references available here do not give enough detail to trace particular relationships or to say which men personally knew one another.
The network, stated cautiously
The documented connections can be represented this way:
Dominic
→ founded and organized the Order; promoted study and preaching
→ Jordan of Saxony, his successor and an early biographer
→ Albert the Great, drawn to the Order by Jordan’s preaching and given the habit by him
→ Thomas Aquinas, a Dominican and Albert’s student and friend
↔ Peter of Tarentaise, connected with Albert and Thomas in work on Dominican study regulations.
The solid links are Jordan–Dominic, Jordan–Albert, Albert–Thomas, and the institutional association of Albert, Thomas, and Peter. The further back one tries to push the chain for the other scholars, the evidence supplied here becomes too thin to distinguish direct contact from mere membership in the same developing Order. 1 2 5 9 8 6
Histories and early sources to consult
The material available here does not identify a single modern, comprehensive history of the Order’s entire first century. It does, however, point to several useful starting places for reconstructing its beginnings and institutions:
• Jordan of Saxony’s Libellus de principiis Ordinis Praedicatorum is an early account of the Order’s origins and Dominic. Jordan’s testimony is especially important for understanding Dominic’s character and the founder-to-successor connection. 2
• Francis C. Lehner, ed., St. Dominic: Biographical Documents includes the Primitive Constitutions. Those documents help explain the Order’s common life, obedience, and study—important context for understanding how Dominic’s foundation shaped later Dominican scholars. 12
• The Monumenta Ordinis Praedicatorum historica and the ** Cartulaire de St Dominique** are identified as collections of early Dominican historical material and documents. The Cartulaire is described as particularly document-rich, though it focuses chiefly on Dominic and the foundation rather than offering a complete narrative of the first century. 13
• Pierre Mandonnet, St. Dominic and His Work is a substantial study of Dominic and his achievement, useful for the founder and the first stage of the Order’s development, but it is not identified here as a comprehensive history of the Order through 1316. 14
For the Albert–Thomas relationship, the supplied materials also point to Jean-Pierre Torrell’s Saint Thomas Aquinas: The Person and His Work and to scholarly studies of Albert’s influence on Thomas. These are useful for the later part of the network, but do not, on their own, supply the missing biographical links for every early Dominican scholar. 9 12
[1] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume I, page359. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/3c7d2cbf-a41f-4fbc-acb1-ab6a917f47fe/ref/page359
[2] General Audience of 3 February 2010, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/a7b79d58-fa61-4e68-bc3f-0fac17ed1d67/ref/page1
[3] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page265. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page265
[4] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page266. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page266
[5] Alberto Magno (1206-1280) - General Audience (2010), page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/91eb3b95-6759-4c22-ad30-4e1f72e86c94/ref/page1
[6] Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Albertus Magnus. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/f2c979a8-871d-4f46-a059-320d3b837a76/ref/St.%20Albertus%20Magnus
[7] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume IV, page349. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27fe0d57-cd5a-44e9-b92b-302d778b1d79/ref/page349
[8] General Audience of 2 June 2010: Saint Thomas Aquinas, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/2b20e842-e703-4dac-979e-c1973c7ba480/ref/page1
[9] Aquinas as Interpreter of Augustinian Illumination in Light of Albertus Magnus, page2. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/a99f2701-0519-42b2-bd20-315542bf291a/ref/page2
[10] General Audience of 2 June 2010, page1. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/9bfe7812-f981-4e00-9a42-537426fa161e/ref/page1
[11] Sacramental Wisdom: Humilitatio, Eruditio, Exercitatio in the Scholastics and Today, page9. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/c973f572-72d7-478d-9af2-242e414cdecc/ref/page9
[12] The Importance of Rapture in the Thought of Aquinas, page25. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/5f95b23e-ffdc-49a5-8367-476e265bf16b/ref/page25
[13] Butler's Lives of the Saints: Volume III, page267. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/27b2019e-dfde-455f-9831-d0458ff162e3/ref/page267
[14] Thomists at War: Pierre Mandonnet, Étienne Gilson, and the Contested Relationship between Aquinas’s and Dante’s Thought (1879–2021), page3. https://www.magisterium.com/docs/01ff26bf-3bae-4ec3-af00-b4fbb04a8839/ref/page3
No comments yet. Be the first to say something!